ISSN - Versão Impressa: 0102-3616 ISSN - Versão Online: 1982-4378

Acesso aberto Revisado por pares
Article Review

Subscapular Osteochondroma as a Differential Diagnosis of Winged Scapula*

Osteocondroma retroescapular como diagnóstico diferencial de escápula alada*

Marco Aurélio de Oliveira1, Yuri Alfaro1, Anastácio Kotzias1, Mário César Korman1

DOI: 10.1055/s-0039-1692432



OBJECTIVE This study aims to report the clinical features of pediatric patients diagnosed with subscapular osteochondroma submitted to surgical treatment at Hospital Infantil Joana de Gusmão (HIJG), in Florianópolis, Santa Catarina, Brazil, between 2003 and 2017.
METHODS Analytical, descriptive and retrospective case series of seven patients with subscapular osteochondroma diagnosis.
RESULTS The average age of the analyzed patients was 9.5 years-old; 71% of the patients were male. The mean time between onset of symptoms and the surgical procedure was 1.2 years. Approximately 71% of the patients presented osteochondroma in the right scapula, and 57.1% of the lesions were classified as sessile. At the clinical examination, winged scapula was observed in 85.7%, crepitus in 71.4%, and 42.9% of the patients complained about pain.
CONCLUSION The winged scapula can have different etiologies, including subscapular osteochondroma. The knowledge about functional anatomy and orthopedic semiology added to the correct systematization approach to bone tumors is the basis for the correct differential diagnosis and adequate treatment.

osteochondroma; scapula; bone neoplasms.


OBJETIVO O objetivo do presente trabalho é relatar as características clínicas de pacientes pediátricos com diagnóstico de osteocondroma retroescapular submetidos a tratamento cirúrgico, entre os anos de 2003 e 2017.
MÉTODOS Série de casos, analítica, descritiva e retrospectiva de sete pacientes com diagnóstico de osteocondroma retroescapular.
RESULTADOS A média de idade dos pacientes analisados foi de 9,5 anos, sendo 71% deles do sexo masculino. O tempo médio entre o início dos sintomas e o procedimento cirúrgico foi de 1,2 anos. Aproximadamente 71% dos pacientes apresentaram osteocondroma na escápula direita, e 57,1% dos casos foram classificados como sésseis. Ao exame clínico, observou-se pseudoescápula alada em 85,7%, crepitação em 71,4%, e queixa de dor em 42,9% dos pacientes.
CONCLUSÃO A escápula alada pode ter diferentes etiologias, dentre elas o osteocondroma retroescapular. O conhecimento sobre anatomia funcional e semiologia ortopédica somado à correta sistematização da abordagem dos tumores ósseos consiste na base para o correto diagnóstico diferencial e tratamento adequado.

osteocondroma; escápula; neoplasias ósseas.


Citation: Oliveira MA, Alfaro Y, Kotzias Neto A, Korman MC. Subscapular Osteochondroma as a Differential Diagnosis of Winged Scapula*. 54(3):241. doi:10.1055/s-0039-1692432
Note: * This study was performed at Hospital Infantil Joana de Gusmão (HIJG), Florianópolis, SC, Brazil.
Received: February 24 2018; Accepted: July 24 2018


An osteochondroma is a bone exostosis in which a continuous cortical layer projects from the underlying bone, is filled with cancellous bone and covered by a cartilaginous tissue of 1 to 3 mm in thickness. It is probably originated from a growth modification of the physeal plate, which accompanies the growth rate and results in an appearance of bony prominences.1

Osteochondromas account for 10 to 15% of all bone tumors. They are the most common benign bone tumors, corresponding to 30 to 50% of the cases.2,3 Most osteochondromas are single lesions, which can occur in two forms: sessile or pedunculated. They mainly affect the metaphyseal region of long bones, especially the knee (distal femur and proximal tibia) and the proximal humerus, and rarely occur on flat bones. However, it is the most common benign tumor of the scapula, accounting for approximately 5% of such lesions2,3 (Fig. 1).

Osteochondromas are most common in patients younger than 30 years-old, and its prevalence is higher in males, with a 1:5 ratio.4,5 Malignant osteochondromas are rare to malignant, occurring in approximately 2% of the cases when in solitary form.6,7

The winged scapula (scapula alata) is a syndrome with several etiologies, and the most common cause related to long thoracic nerve injury. However, subscapular osteochondroma is an important differential diagnosis, and, in this case, the disorder is referred to as pseudo-winging of the scapula and characterized by a mobile or fixed scapular deformity.8,9 Described by McWilliams in 1914, the pseudo-winging of the scapula secondary to an osteochondroma is difficult to differentiate from the winged scapula resulting from long thoracic nerve lesion; therefore, it must always be included among the diagnostic possibilities for this type of clinical manifestation.10,11

The literature has few studies relating the winged scapula to subscapular osteochondromas, and most of them are case reports.

Therefore, this study aims to report the clinical features of pediatric patients diagnosed with subscapular osteochondroma and submitted to surgical treatment at Hospital Infantil Joana de Gusmão (HIJG), in Florianópolis, SC, Brazil.

This study was approved by the Ethics and Research Committee of HIJG under the number 2.213.465.



This study is an analytical, descriptive, and retrospective case series.

Seven medical reports from children aged 4 to 14 years-old, admitted for subscapular osteochondroma resection at the orthopedics and traumatology department of a children's hospital (Hospital Infantil de Ortopedia e Traumatologia) from February 2003 to March 2017, were analyzed.

The instrument for data collection was constructed by the authors through a protocol developed for this study, which addresses socioeconomic characteristics, age, gender, and location of the lesion, in addition to a descriptive analysis of tumoral and clinical features of the patients studied.

The collected information was stored in an electronic database (Excel). Categorical variables were described as absolute (n) and relative (%) frequency. The statistical analysis was performed with the SPSS Statistics for Windows, Version 22.0 software (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA).



The medical records from 7 patients diagnosed with subscapular osteochondroma and submitted to the surgical treatment at HIJG between 2003 and 2017 were analyzed.

Among these patients, 71% were male. Their average age was 9 years, 5 months-old, ranging from 4 to 14 years-old. The average time from symptoms onset to surgery was 1 year, 2 months.

According to the tumor-related characteristics, 5 patients (71.4%) presented the scapula osteochondroma on the right side and 2 (28.6%), on the left side. Of this total, 57.1% were sessile lesions, and the tumor was in the scapular region (solitary) in approximately 43% of the cases (Fig. 2).

Regarding the clinical picture, most patients, namely 85.6%, presented pseudo-winging of the scapula at the physical examination, whereas crepitation was noted in 71.4% of the children. Less than half of the patients (42.9%) complained of pain. Out of the seven patients, three had bursitis (Table 1).

Table 1. Database
Name Gender Age Evolution Time Side Solitary/Multiple Sessile/Pedunculated Pain Winged Scapula Crepitation Bursitis
1 M 14 1.7 Right Solitary Pedunculated No Yes Yes Yes
2 M 14 0.9 Right Multiple Sessile Yes Yes Yes No
3 F 6 1.3 Left Multiple Sessile No Yes Yes No
4 M 4 1.2 Right Multiple Pedunculated No Yes No No
5 M 12 1.8 Left Solitary Sessile Yes Yes Yes Yes
6 F 10 1.2 Right Multiple Sessile No Yes Yes No
7 M 7 0.7 Right Solitary Pedunculated Yes No No Yes

As for cases distribution, among the observed variables, there was a predominance of the right side, “winged” (snapping), and absence of bursitis (six among seven cases for all these variables). Regarding type, form, pain and crepitation, there was a balance between presence and absence (Table 2).

Table 2. Statistical analysis
Variable Frequency (%)
    Left 1 (14.3)
    Right 6 (85.7)
    Solitary 3 (42.9)
    Multiple 4 (57.1)
    Sessile 3 (42.9)
    Pedunculated 4 (57.1)
    Present 3 (42.9)
    Absent 4 (57.1)
"Winged Scapula" (Snapping)
    Yes 1 (14.3)
    No 6 (85.7)
    Yes 4 (57.1)
    No 3 (42.9)
    Yes 1 (14.3)
    No 6 (85.7)


Osteochondroma accounts for 30 to 50% of benign bone tumors, but only 4% of scapular tumors. McWilliams was the first author to describe an osteochondroma with scapular deformity in a case report published in 1914.10

Osteochondroma is the most common benign tumor in the metaphyseal region of long bones and rarely affects flat bones; however, it is the most frequent benign tumor in the scapula.2,3

Its presence, and, therefore, its diagnosis is noted due to the growth and increased volume in the scapular region at ectoscopy. Clinical manifestations, such as local pain, are usually delayed and may be secondary to neurovascular structures compression, bursa thickening (when present), peduncle fracture, or malignant transformation. Other symptoms, such as scapular protuberance, crepitation, edema, and loss of mobility, may be present depending on the size and location of the tumor, both in the sagittal and coronal planes.12 The “pseudo-winging of the scapula” is observed when the tumor is located in the medial, inferior, and ventral border of the scapula, where the tumor concavity is dislocated over the convex aspect of the rib cage, leading the scapula to the lateral region of the shoulder girdle. It happens when the patient performs the abduction associated with the internal shoulder rotation.13 This picture is very similar to the long thoracic nerve paralysis, in which the integrity of the serratus anterior muscle is evaluated through a maneuver in which the patient pushes a surface longitudinal to the axis of the upper limbs with both elbows in extension. This test is considered positive when there is an excessive scapular lateral dislocation that is asymmetric to the contralateral side, thus resulting in a “winged scapula” (Fig. 3).

Differential diagnoses for winged scapula also include amyotrophic neuralgia, nerve damage, scapulothoracic dyskinesias, and any other fascioscapular thoracic dystrophy12,14 (Fig. 4).

Fiddian e Wing15 classified the winged scapula according to its mobility as static (A) or dynamic (B), and, per its anatomical origin, in four types: type I, resulting from nervous lesion (most common), type II, related to a muscle lesion, type III, per bone etiology, and type IV, per joint damage. All studied patients were classified as dynamic winged scapula with bone origin (B-III)

The malignant transformation of the osteochondroma is uncommon. In solitary forms, it occurs in approximately 2% of the cases and, in multiple forms, around 27%.16 The literature highlights that the thickness of the cartilaginous layer is a predictive factor for aggressiveness, that is, a thickness higher than 2.0 cm is a strong indicator of malignant transformation, and it is associated with marginal calcification.12,16 As for clinical manifestations, it is necessary to keep in mind the osteochondroma growth after skeletal maturity, since these tumors tend to stop growing during the second decade of life. In all our operated cases, the resected material was referred to the pathological anatomy service, and the presence of malignant cells was ruled out.

The postresection osteochondroma recurrence rate is around 2%, and it is due to the presence of residual cartilage and its perichondrium after the surgical procedure.17 There was no tumor recurrence in our study.

Radiographic studies in anteroposterior, lateral scapular and axillary views are enough for lesion identification. In case of difficult interpretation, a computed tomography can be useful to improve the access strategy. Since it is a cartilaginous lesion, a magnetic resonance scan is an excellent adjunct technique, mainly to evaluate the cartilaginous layer thickening and the presence and extension of the bursa.

Several authors describe the presence of a bursa between the osteochondroma and the involved soft tissues (dorsal and serratus anterior muscles) due to the friction between the tumor and the rib cage, resulting in the formation of synovial fluid and causing local pain because of the inflammatory process.18 Orlow,19 in 1891, was the first author to describe it, using the term exostosis bursata. In our study, there were 3 cases with bursa formation, including 2 with local pain; this can be a suspicion factor, considering that, among those who did not present it (57%), only 1 child complained of pain.

There was no relationship between the analyzed data to support any conclusion as per type, form, evolution time, pain, crepitation and presence of pseudo-winging of the scapula. Data are isolated and not correlated.

This topic was chosen to highlight an organizational chart for diagnosis. While complaints regarding osteochondromas are relatively usual at orthopedics outpatient facilities, this presentation is not common, and it can go unnoticed, resulting in an untimely diagnosis.

Since this is a rare event, the sample size does not allow the determination of possible relationships between variables. Therefore, further studies are required, increasing the collection time or the experimental field to gather more information.

The main limitation of this study lies in its retrospective and observational design and in the lack of a control group. However, our case series is larger when compared to a literature review on the subject, since most papers are case reports.



The winged scapula can have several etiologies, including the subscapular osteochondroma. The knowledge of the functional anatomy and orthopedics semiology, in addition to the correct systematization for bone tumors approach, is the basis for the correct differential diagnosis and proper treatment.



Ermiş MN, Aykut US, Durakbaşa MO, Ozel MS, Bozkuş FS, Karakaş ES. Snapping scapula syndrome caused by subscapular osteochondroma. Eklem Hastalik Cerrahisi 2012;23(01): 40–43
Unni KK, Inwards CY, Dahlin DC. Dhalin’s bone tumors: general aspects and data on 10,165 cases. 6th ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2010
Mohsen MS, Moosa NK, Kumar P. Osteochondroma of the scapula associated with winging and large bursa formation. Med Princ Pract 2006;15(05):387–390 Link DOI
Galate JF, Blue JM, Gaines RW. Osteochondroma of the scapula. Mo Med 1995;92(02):95–97
Bovée JV. Multiple osteochondromas. Orphanet J Rare Dis 2008; 3:3 Link DOI
Dharmadhikari RP. Painful Snapping and Pseudo-winging Scapula due to a large Scapular Osteochondroma. J Orthop Case Rep 2012; 2(02):10–13
Ahmed AR, Tan TS, Unni KK, Collins MS, Wenger DE, Sim FH. Secondary chondrosarcoma in osteochondroma: report of 107 patients. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2003;(411):193–206 Link DOI
Chillemi C, Franceschini V, Ippolito G, Pasquali R, Diotallevi R, Petrozza V, et al. Osteochondroma as a cause of scapular winging in an adolescent: a case report and review of the literature. J Med Case Reports 2013;7:220 Link DOI
Flugstad NA, Sanger JR, Hackbarth DA. Pseudo-winging of the scapula caused by scapular osteochondroma: review of literature and case report. Hand (N Y) 2015;10(02):353–356 Link DOI
McWilliams CA. Subscapular exostosis. JAMA 1914;LXIII(17): 1473–1474 437705 Link DOI
Martin RM, Fish DE. Scapular winging: anatomical review, diagnosis, and treatments. Curr Rev Musculoskelet Med 2008;1(01): 1–11 Link DOI
Jindal M. Delayed Presentation of Osteochondroma at Superior Angle of Scapula-A Case Report. J Orthop Case Rep 2016;6(03): 32–34
Walter J, Kiely N, Cool P, Tyrrell P, Quinlivan RM. An unusual case of scapula winging. Neuromuscul Disord 2013;23(03): 277–278 Link DOI
Orth P, Anagnostakos K, Fritsch E, Kohn D, Madry H. Static winging of the scapula caused by osteochondroma in adults: a case series. J Med Case Reports 2012;6:363 Link DOI
Fiddian NJ, King RJ. The winged scapula. Clin Orthop Relat Res 1984;(185):228–236 Link DOI
Garrison RC, Unni KK, McLeod RA, Pritchard DJ, Dahlin DC. Chondrosarcoma arising in osteochondroma. Cancer 1982;49 (09):1890–1897 Link DOI
Ceberut K, Korkmaz M, Ergin I, Müslehiddinoglu A. Bursa formation with scapular osteochondroma in hereditary multiple exostosis. J Coll Physicians Surg Pak 2013;23(07):512–514
Ali AA, Sharma P, Rege R, Seena CR, Rajesh S. Exostosis Bursata - Multimodality Imaging Approach. J Clin Diagn Res 2016;10(09): TD03–TD04 Link DOI
Orlow LW. Die exostosis bursata und ihreentstehung. Dtsch Z Chir 1891:293–308 Link DOI

*Trabalho feito no Hospital Infantil Joana de Gusmão, Florianópolis, SC, Brasil.